[ { "register_no": "PDO-01", "id": "nadra-civil-registry", "name": "Civil registry and national identity database", "agency": "National Database and Registration Authority (NADRA)", "status": "coded", "T": 62.5, "S": 65.3, "TSI": 63.9, "p05": 48, "p95": 76.9, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/website-governance", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105316/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/website-governance", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/ac090447102a.pdf", "passage": "NADRA is mandated to register all citizens and legal residents of Pakistan and to establish, maintain, and operate secure multipurpose national identity databases and digital infrastructure to support public service delivery, governance, and national development.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Services Charter, p. 1, adds what the identity is used for: elections, healthcare, education, social security, communication and financial services." }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/verification", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105335/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/verification", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/8f6fd3cd4a7e.pdf", "passage": "In line with the mandate specified in Clause (i) of Subsection (1) of Section 7 of NADRA Ordinance, 2000", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Services Charter, p. 4, also cites section 7 for the National Data Warehouse and Citizen Database." }, "T1.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 4: It is a comprehensive repository, storing data such as biometric information, demographic details, and identity records.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Charter p. 22 lists the fields a card holder can change: name, father/husband name, date of birth, addresses, gender, marital status, education, mobile number, email." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 30: Verification Services Department ... 051-9108134; Public Information Officer (pio@nadra.gov.pk)", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Departmental and helpline contacts are published. No named officer or office responsible for citizens' data (no data protection officer or equivalent) was found." }, "T2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 13, Other stakeholders, Public: Judiciary; Security Exchange Commission of Pakistan; Election Commission of Pakistan; State Bank of Pakistan; Pakistan Bureau of Statistics; Federal Board of Revenue; Pakistan Telecommunication Authority; Benazir Income Support Program; Law Enforcement Agencies. Private: Insurance Companies; Financial Institutions; Telecom Operators ...", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Charter pp. 25-27 describe the verification services through which these bodies query the database. Named bodies count without a formal register of agreements (reading rule R-3)." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Services Charter; Terms & Conditions page; verification page; About NADRA. tenders.nadra.gov.pk was not opened.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/term-and-condition", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105418/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/term-and-condition", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/ea2dee8e5790.pdf", "passage": "We store your data on our secure servers in Pakistan.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Location is stated. Nothing states whether any citizen data is transferred abroad (NADRA runs identity projects for other countries)." }, "T3.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 4: every citizen has the right to access certain categories of information held by NADRA by submitting a written request to the NADRA's Public Information Officer (PIO) ... requests will be processed within 10 days.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The site's Right to Information page explains how to file a request; charter p. 30 gives the PIO's email and address. The two links printed in the charter (public-information-officer, RTI-Request-Form.pdf) are old addresses." }, "T3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/nadraStatistics", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105437/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/nadraStatistics", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/12751ea0acb6.pdf", "passage": "NADRA Footprint; NADRA's 25 Year Book", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "NADRA publishes statistics and a 25-year book. The charter, p. 3, says its accounts are audited by chartered accountants appointed in consultation with the Auditor General, but no audit or evaluation report was found on the site." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Services Charter; Terms & Conditions page; NR&BP Framework v2.0; Downloads (Policies, Notifications, Guidelines).", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The government's own NR&BP Framework, notified 1 January 2025, says at p. 24: 'There is no requirement for conducting Data Protection Impact Assessments (DPIAs) before implementing new technologies or processing activities involving biometric data.'" }, "S1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/term-and-condition", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105418/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/term-and-condition", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/ea2dee8e5790.pdf", "passage": "This privacy policy explains how NADRA manages the personal information it collects from applicants at the time of filing application for ID cards.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Published under Terms & Conditions. Covers site data, PakID app data and biometric data." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/term-and-condition", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105418/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/term-and-condition", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/ea2dee8e5790.pdf", "passage": "Biometric data used for verification is not retained after the session. If the user opts to update their photograph or fingerprint, that new data is securely transmitted and permanently stored in NADRA's official identity database.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Retention is stated for biometric data only. Nothing on how long demographic records, or records of deceased persons, are kept." }, "S1.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 2: personal information of the citizen is only used for the purposes for which it was collected and is not disclosed to third parties without proper authorization.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The privacy policy adds that biometric data is 'used strictly for' identity verification and record updates." }, "S2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 6: Access to Information: The right to access their personal information held by NADRA and to request corrections if necessary.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Routes published in the charter: Family Registration Certificate (p. 24), SMS 8009 for family-tree verification (p. 26), PakID app. A published route to obtain one's record in any form counts (reading rule R-5)." }, "S2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 21: ID Card Holder seeking update of demographic details must submit relevant documents as per list of acceptable documents mentioned in NADRA Registration Policy", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Charter p. 22 lists which fields can be changed and how often." }, "S2.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105412/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/nadra-services-charter-1-0-0.pdf", "passage": "p. 28: Approximately 93% of complaints are resolved within seven days. ... Grievances through this channel are properly recorded on a complaint register ... and their resolution is ensured within 15 days.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Channels: NCCMS portal, 1777, PMDU, complaint registers, open forums. The time limits are for service complaints generally; none is specific to data misuse." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/biometric-block-unblock.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105455/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/assests/downloadsPdf/biometric-block-unblock.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/biometric-block-unblock.pdf", "passage": "p. 2: The Block or Enable Biometric Verification feature in the PakID app lets you control who can access your personal data and biometric information stored with NADRA.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A citizen can block verification and, for Digital ID, must consent to each share. The Digital ID Citizen Guide, p. 5, says 'all data access and usage is recorded' but does not say the citizen can see that record." }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Terms & Conditions / privacy policy (no breach clause); Services Charter; first page of Media Releases (April-September 2026); NR&BP Framework.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The NR&BP Framework, pp. 24-25, itself records the 'absence of mandatory breach notification protocols'." }, "S3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.nadra.gov.pk/verification", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105335/https://www.nadra.gov.pk/verification", "evidence_file": "evidence/nadra-civil-registry/8f6fd3cd4a7e.pdf", "passage": "Revision of agreements incorporating Information Security Protocols ... Incorporation of Two-factor authentication ... Revamped APIs to ensure data privacy", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Security measures are asserted. The charter's audit section (p. 3) covers financial accounts only. No independent security auditor, certification or date is named on the site." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-02", "id": "fbr-iris", "name": "IRIS taxpayer system", "agency": "Federal Board of Revenue (FBR)", "status": "coded", "T": 69.4, "S": 40.3, "TSI": 52.9, "p05": 44, "p95": 62, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://iris.fbr.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/54a9ac20104d.pdf", "passage": "IRIS 2.0 ... helps you file your FBR income tax return easily", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The IRIS page describes itself this way. PRAL's site calls IRIS 'Pakistan's largest e-filing system'." }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://download1.fbr.gov.pk/Docs/2020122914123835238ProfileUpdate-UserGuide.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/2020122914123835238ProfileUpdate-UserGuide.pdf", "passage": "User Guide – Profile Update u/s 114A of the income Tax Ordinance, 2001", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "FBR's own guide to the system cites the section it implements." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://iris.fbr.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/54a9ac20104d.pdf", "passage": "simplified income tax form, income and wealth statements, and e-filing", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The kinds of statement filed are named; there is no list of the personal data the system holds." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.fbr.gov.pk/ask-fbr/173354", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104734/https://www.fbr.gov.pk/ask-fbr/173354", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/6e171231cde2.pdf", "passage": "You can contact the FBR Helpline through the following channels: i) Telephone: +92 51 111 772 772", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "General helpline and query form only. No named officer for IRIS data." }, "T2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://pakistancode.gov.pk/pdffiles/administratorc09ecd376211abe32a7e44510f3fd719.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104802/https://pakistancode.gov.pk/pdffiles/administratorc09ecd376211abe32a7e44510f3fd719.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/administratorc09ecd376211abe32a7e44510f3fd719.pdf", "passage": "s.216(3)(s), p. 467: to the Financial Monitoring Unit (FMU) for the purpose of performing functions as laid down in the Anti-Money Laundering Act, 2010 (VII of 2010) ... s.216(6A), p. 468: Nothing contained in sub-section (1) shall prevent the Board from providing data to any person approved by the Federal Government to process and analyze such data for broadening of tax base or for checking evasion", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Section 216(3) lists the bodies and purposes for which taxpayer particulars may be disclosed (pp. 463 to 468 of the text on pakistancode.gov.pk, amended to 30 June 2026)." }, "T2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pral.com.pk/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/799eb2e47dd4.pdf", "passage": "PRAL manages FBR's Helpline ... Pakistan's largest e-filing system, IRIS is one of the best integrated systems in the country", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Pakistan Revenue Automation (Pvt) Ltd lists IRIS among the systems it builds and runs for FBR. PRAL's site says it is 'instrumental in helping Federal Board of Revenue' and does not state who owns it." }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fbr.gov.pk Privacy Policy and Terms of Use (no storage location); pral.com.pk ('management of computer and server operations', no location, nothing on transfers abroad); iris.fbr.gov.pk.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://fbr.gov.pk/public-relations-job-description/142248/173819", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104849/https://fbr.gov.pk/public-relations-job-description/142248/173819", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/29422743af90.pdf", "passage": "Designated PIO (Public Information Officer) / Secretary (Compliance) ... Ms. Kiran Zahra ... 051-9201307 ... ss.compliance@fbr.gov.pk ... Prescribed form (Request for Information)", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Named officer with contact details and a prescribed request form. The page does not cite the Act or explain the steps." }, "T3.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://agp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Policy/AR%20on%20accountof%20federal%20board%20of%20revenue%202024-25.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/AGP-audit-report-FBR-2024-25.pdf", "passage": "p. 19: should put in place validation checks while generating Computerized Payment Receipts (CPRs) in the E-Portal of Inland Revenue Information System (IRIS), to ensure that no CPR is generated without filling of mandatory fields, to plug the loopholes in the electronic tax collection system.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Auditor General's Audit Report on the accounts of the Federal Board of Revenue, Audit Year 2024-25 (224 pages), linked from agp.gov.pk/AuditReports. It makes an audit recommendation on controls in IRIS and refers to PRAL's data at pp. 23, 25 and 168 to 170." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fbr.gov.pk Privacy Policy; fbr.gov.pk publications list; pral.com.pk.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.fbr.gov.pk/Privacy-Policy/543", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104917/https://www.fbr.gov.pk/Privacy-Policy/543", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/00f2edb7acff.pdf", "passage": "This policy is applicable only to official website of FBR", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The policy excludes FBR's online systems, saying e-filing systems 'may have their own Terms of Use'. None was found for IRIS. The IRIS login page, read on 9 October 2026, links no terms or privacy notice." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fbr.gov.pk Privacy Policy (no retention); Terms of Use; pral.com.pk. The Ordinance's records section binds taxpayers, not FBR.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://pakistancode.gov.pk/pdffiles/administratorc09ecd376211abe32a7e44510f3fd719.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104802/https://pakistancode.gov.pk/pdffiles/administratorc09ecd376211abe32a7e44510f3fd719.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/administratorc09ecd376211abe32a7e44510f3fd719.pdf", "passage": "s.216(1), p. 463: shall be confidential and no public servant save as provided in this Ordinance may disclose any such particulars.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A confidentiality rule with listed exceptions, read in the official text amended to 30 June 2026. It restricts disclosure; it does not limit what FBR itself may use the data for." }, "S2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://download1.fbr.gov.pk/Docs/2020122914123835238ProfileUpdate-UserGuide.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/2020122914123835238ProfileUpdate-UserGuide.pdf", "passage": "Click option \"My Profile\" on the Top right side of the screen", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A taxpayer can log in and view the profile FBR holds." }, "S2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://download1.fbr.gov.pk/Docs/2020122914123835238ProfileUpdate-UserGuide.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/2020122914123835238ProfileUpdate-UserGuide.pdf", "passage": "Fields with sign can be edited for updating data/ profile ... After changes are verified, Profile u/s 114A will be updated.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Published procedure for correcting profile data. The guide does not list which fields can be changed." }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.fbr.gov.pk/pakistan-citizen-portal-pcp/81166/152494", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/15b96e2634b4.pdf", "passage": "Regular update and real time tracking regarding the status of complaints", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Five complaint routes are listed (Chairman, Federal Tax Ombudsman, ADR, e-CRM, Citizen Portal). No response time is stated and none mentions data misuse." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fbr.gov.pk Privacy Policy; Profile Update guide; pral.com.pk.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fbr.gov.pk Privacy Policy and Terms of Use (no breach clause); FBR press-release search for the August 2021 attack found press reports of an FBR press conference (ProPakistani, 1 September 2021) but no FBR statement.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Press reporting cannot support a code. If FBR published a statement on the 2021 incident, this becomes 0.5." }, "S3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.pral.com.pk/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fbr-iris/799eb2e47dd4.pdf", "passage": "ISO CERTIFICATIONS", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "PRAL's home page shows certificate badges under this heading, one of them for ISO 27001, with no certifier, scope or date." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-03", "id": "dgip-passports", "name": "Passport issuance system", "agency": "Directorate General of Immigration and Passports (Ministry of Interior)", "status": "coded", "T": 36.1, "S": 27.8, "TSI": 31.7, "p05": 16.4, "p95": 45.5, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/passport/process.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/de30ae7fa067.pdf", "passage": "The applicant will go through the following steps ... Capturing of Photograph + Token Issuance with QR Code. Biometrics/Finger Prints capture. Data Entry. Verification as per Office Record. (ECL/BL). Interview and Decision by Assistant Director.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The passport policy page states what the document is for; the process page states what the system records and checks." }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/downloads/PassportRules-2021.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/PassportRules-2021.pdf", "passage": "S.R.O. 245(I)/2022. In exercise of the powers conferred by section 13 of the Passports Act, 1974 (XX of 1974) read with section 3 of the Foreigners Act, 1946 (XXXI of 1946) ... Passports Rules, 2021", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Act and Rules are published on the site's downloads page." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/eServices/epassport.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/aa6573be5a2c.pdf", "passage": "The chip contains data that will verify the passport holder's identity and will include the biometrics of the passport holder, the personal data found on the data page of the passport, a unique identification number and a digital signature.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Describes what the chip holds and, on the process page, what is captured (photograph, CNIC number, fingerprints). No list of what the passport database holds." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/contactus/contact.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/6ad2cbd5bd8c.pdf", "passage": "Director (Software Application and Production) Mr. Muhammad Abdul Khaliq 9107016", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A named head of software with a telephone number. The title does not say the post is responsible for passport records or applicants' data, so this is coded partly disclosed under reading rule R-1." }, "T2.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/downloads/PassportRules-2021.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/PassportRules-2021.pdf", "passage": "r.22(4), p. 12: such passport shall be inactivated ... and placed on the Integrated Border Management System (IBMS) for refusal of immigration services.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Rules name IBMS and refer doubtful cases to 'the concerned security agency'; the process page mentions checks against ECL and blacklist records. No list of bodies with access." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "dgip.gov.pk tenders page (six notices, no contractor named); e-Passport page; contact page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "dgip.gov.pk Terms of Use; e-Passport page; Passports Rules 2021.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/contactus/contact.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/6ad2cbd5bd8c.pdf", "passage": "Public Information Officer: Mr. Fiaz Hussain (Director) Contact No. : 051-9107075", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The officer is named with a number. Nothing explains how to file a request." }, "T3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "dgip.gov.pk sitemap (no reports section); About us; Office Orders not opened.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The home page carries an image titled '2025 performance'." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "dgip.gov.pk sitemap; Terms of Use; Passports Rules 2021.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/home/terms.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/cbf6a55970d0.pdf", "passage": "When using this website, you are agreeing to all of these terms on how we collect and store your personal data. ... Any personally identifying information will not be disclosed to any third party.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Website terms only. They do not mention passport applications or the passport database." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/downloads/PassportRules-2021.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/PassportRules-2021.pdf", "passage": "r.22, p. 11: normal period of retaining a person on the PCL is five years.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A retention period is stated for the Passport Control List only. Nothing on how long application and biometric records are kept." }, "S1.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Passports Rules 2021 (keyword search: confidential, disclose, share); Terms of Use (website data only).", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/updates/sms-passport-tracking-system.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/6cf0364fa483.pdf", "passage": "SMS based Passport Tracking Intimation System", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "An applicant can track an application. No way to see the record held." }, "S2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/passport/ordinary-passport.php#Modification", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/bb0d42629373.pdf", "passage": "The applicant can apply for a passport to modify his/her name, father name, date of birth etc. For it, he has to get his CNIC/NICOP revise/modify first.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.dgip.gov.pk/contactus/contact.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/dgip-passports/6ad2cbd5bd8c.pdf", "passage": "Please choose one of the following methods of communication for your queries & complaints ... or you can register complaint through Pakistan Citizen's Portal.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Helpline, email and portal. No response time. The Rules give an appeal and periodic review for people placed on the Passport Control List." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Terms of Use; Passports Rules 2021; FAQs.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Terms of Use; sitemap; home-page notices.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "e-Passport page (says the document complies with ICAO standards, which concerns the booklet, not an audit of the system); Terms of Use; tenders.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-04", "id": "fia-ibms", "name": "Integrated Border Management System (IBMS)", "agency": "Federal Investigation Agency (FIA)", "status": "coded", "T": 47.2, "S": 9.7, "TSI": 21.4, "p05": 11.7, "p95": 29.3, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/ibms", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/3080e19c0aca.pdf", "passage": "to keep an eye on all incoming and outgoing international travelers ... to support Law Enforcement Agencies (LEAs) & Intelligence Agencies (IAs) in fight against terrorism", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The page also shows stop-list tables. The Annual Administration Report 2024, p. 31, says 3509 cases were intercepted on the basis of the stop-list." }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/ibms", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/3080e19c0aca.pdf", "passage": "on the basis of FIA Act 1974 and Foreigners Registration Act 1964", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Statutes cited by name and year on the system's own page. Whether they actually authorise the database is a legal question the index does not judge." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/ibms", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/3080e19c0aca.pdf", "passage": "Database of more than 206 million travelers based on arrival / departure since 2003.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Arrival and departure records are mentioned; no list of the fields held (passport data, photographs, biometrics)." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/ibms", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/3080e19c0aca.pdf", "passage": "Email: complaints@fia.gov.pk ... Helpline: 051-111-345-786 & 1991", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "General FIA contact only. No named office or officer for IBMS data." }, "T2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/files/publications/686234992.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/686234992.pdf", "passage": "p. 31: IBMS / FIA is pioneer in real time data sharing through API's with different Government [bodies]; listed: Pakistan Online Visa System (MOI / NADRA), Currency Declaration System (Pakistan Customs), Device Identification Registration Blocking System (PTA / FBR), Bureau of Emigration & Overseas Employment, E-Passport (Passport Office), Punjab Police, Frontier Works Organization", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Annual Administration Report 2024. The IBMS page separately lists integration with the Financial Monitoring Unit." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms (none; says only 'indigenously developed' in the 2024 report); fia.gov.pk/tenders (18 IBMS tenders listed, no vendor or award named); Annual Administration Report 2024.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Tender notices are published but no contractor is named." }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/privacy; Annual Administration Report 2024; fia.gov.pk/tenders (data-centre cooling tenders imply an in-house data centre but nothing states where data is held).", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/infoact2019", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/51a3ff843d3a.pdf", "passage": "Public Information Officer under the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017 [link to notification]; RTI Request Form under Right of Access to Information Act 2017; Schedule of Costs", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The request form and cost schedule are published. The officer's notification is an image file that could not be read by machine." }, "T3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/files/publications/686234992.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/686234992.pdf", "passage": "p. 31: IBMS Directorate's is maintaining this data which has touched the figure of 21,114,039 travelers. ... 3509 cases have been intercepted at different IBMS sites on the basis of Stop-list.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Annual Administration Report 2024 reports IBMS activity figures; it does not assess the system. The 2025 report (fia.gov.pk/files/tickers/416429854.pdf) timed out and was not read." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/privacy; fia.gov.pk/laws; Annual Administration Report 2024.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/privacy", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/09986f2b5644.pdf", "passage": "We do not collect any information about you unless you choose to provide that information.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Website and mobile-app privacy policies only. Neither mentions immigration or IBMS records." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/privacy and /app_privacy (retention stated for the mobile app only); fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/laws (no retention rule listed); Annual Administration Report 2024.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/privacy (website data only); fia.gov.pk/laws; SOPs listed on the laws page were not opened.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/faq (no entry on obtaining travel history); fia.gov.pk/immigration_w.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/faq; fia.gov.pk/immigration_w; fia.gov.pk/privacy (correction offered for website-submitted information only).", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://fia.gov.pk/immigration_w", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/fia-ibms/0540b3c4a355.pdf", "passage": "Complaints against the staff are being received at the Desk ... the same is resolved then and there by the concerned staff.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Complaint routes exist (desk, portal, email, helpline). None mentions data and none states a response time." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; fia.gov.pk/privacy; fia.gov.pk/faq.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/privacy and /app_privacy (no breach clause); fia.gov.pk/press-pub not opened.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "fia.gov.pk/ibms; Annual Administration Report 2024 (no audit or certification); fia.gov.pk/privacy mentions 'security monitoring, auditing and encryption' for the website only.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-05", "id": "bisp-nser", "name": "National Socio-Economic Registry (NSER)", "agency": "Benazir Income Support Programme (BISP)", "status": "coded", "T": 66.7, "S": 41.7, "TSI": 52.7, "p05": 42.6, "p95": 63.2, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/NSER%20Report%202024.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009103752/https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/NSER%20Report%202024.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/NSER_Report_2024.pdf", "passage": "p. 10: The NSER enables BISP to identify eligible families for both conditional cash and unconditional cash assistance.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009103809/https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "passage": "s.7, p. 12: [BISP Act 2010, section 10(c)] to identify eligible persons or families for financial assistance or other benefits", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "NSER Data Sharing Protocols v3.0 cite the BISP Act 2010 and its section 10(c)." }, "T1.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/Detail/NzI5YTMyYTMtYjE1My00NGUwLTgwYTItZWUwYTZkYWZjYmNj", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/d34b54d76fa0.pdf", "passage": "the registry's roster data (Name, CNIC, Marital Status, Gender, Status of Differently-abled Persons)", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The NSER Annual Report FY 2022-23, p. 1, adds categories: geographic, demographic, family composition, education, employment, assets, dwelling, water and sanitation, agriculture." }, "T1.4": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/FINAL%20NSER%202022-23.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/FINAL_NSER_2022-23.pdf", "passage": "Naveed Akbar, Director General, NSER/CCT ... NSER Operations Team, +92 51-9246326 Ext: 314, dynamic.nser@bisp.gov.pk", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Named post and a contact route specific to the registry. Post-holder as published in the report of July 2023." }, "T2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/FINAL%20NSER%202022-23.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/FINAL_NSER_2022-23.pdf", "passage": "p. 40: Pakistan Bait-ul-Mal; National Poverty Graduation Programme; Sehat Tahafuz Program; Punjab Information Technology Board; Punjab Social Protection Authority; Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund; Food Department, KP; Utility Stores Corporation", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Named bodies integrated for data exchange. The NSER web page adds that 29 organisations requested datasets since January 2022 without listing them." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/FINAL%20NSER%202022-23.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/FINAL_NSER_2022-23.pdf", "passage": "PDF p. 6: our Technological partners, including NADRA and NTC ... PDF p. 18: Implementation arrangements with NADRA and NTC for the operationalization of enhanced data inter-operability ... PDF p. 44: The German Corporation for International Cooperation GmbH (GIZ), through a 3rd party HR firm, provided 1250 human resources", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Public partners are named with roles. The HR firm is not named, and no builder or host of the registry software is named." }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "NSER web page; Data Sharing Protocols v3.0 (says only 'BISP stores such variable in an encrypted manner'); Annual Report FY 2022-23; NSER Report 2024.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/Detail/NWMwMzQwNWItZTUzMS00ODQ4LWJkNmEtYjMwMzZkN2Y3NDU5", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/d8d9d7345ffa.pdf", "passage": "Qurat-ul-Ain Fatima, Director (MCO), 051-9210709 ... Requested information should be provided to you within 10 working days.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Named officer, request form, postal route and time limit." }, "T3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/FINAL%20NSER%202022-23.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/FINAL_NSER_2022-23.pdf", "passage": "National Socio-Economic Registry (Dynamic NSER), Annual Report FY 2022-23, NSER Wing, July 2023", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Self-published and descriptive; it does not evaluate the registry and is more than three years old on 8 October 2026. The NSER Report 2024 is a progress report on mobile registration vans." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "NSER web page; Data Sharing Protocols v3.0; Annual Report FY 2022-23; NSER Report 2024; BISP Laws/Policies list.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009103809/https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "passage": "PDF p. 9: National Socio-Economic Registry Data Sharing Protocols (Version 3.0). This document describes the design and operational methodologies of data sharing and integration for National Socio-Economic Registry (NSER) with other public and private sector organizations, considering value and security of the database. 1st Aug 2022", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A published data policy specific to the registry. It is written for bodies requesting the data, not for the households in it; no notice addressed to households was found. Counted in full under reading rule R-2." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Data Sharing Protocols v3.0 (retention, archiving and deletion not addressed); NSER web page (says data is 'updated every four years', which is a refresh cycle); Annual Report FY 2022-23.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009103809/https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/nser_data_sharing_docs_2023.pdf", "passage": "s.10.1, p. 28: BISP does not share complete data of a Household with any entity.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Protocols set conditions on sharing (committee approval, NDA, classification). Nothing limits BISP's own use, and no limit on recipients' onward use was found." }, "S2.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/NSEREngUrdu_2022.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009103938/https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/NSEREngUrdu_2022.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/NSEREngUrdu_2022.pdf", "passage": "You may check your eligibility status online on https://8171.pass.gov.pk", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A household can check eligibility status, not see its record." }, "S2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/Detail/NzI5YTMyYTMtYjE1My00NGUwLTgwYTItZWUwYTZkYWZjYmNj", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/d34b54d76fa0.pdf", "passage": "Benazir Registration Desks have been established at the tehsil level to cater to missed-out HHs", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Roster updates (birth, death, marital status) are offered at desks and through an Android app; the registration guide says what to bring (CNICs, B-Forms)." }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/f1446bd7caa0.pdf", "passage": "Complaint Cell: Complaint Redressel; PMDU; Procurement Grievances / Complaints Registration", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A complaint menu exists. No response time is stated and nothing mentions data misuse. The 'Complaint Redressel' link is script-driven and could not be opened by machine." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Data Sharing Protocols v3.0 (s.8.2.3 requires BISP to log each data request internally; no way for a household to see the log); NSER web page; registration guide.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Data Sharing Protocols v3.0 (incident and breach handling not addressed); NSER web page; Annual Report FY 2022-23; NSER Report 2024.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.bisp.gov.pk/SiteImage/Misc/files/FINAL%20NSER%202022-23.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/bisp-nser/FINAL_NSER_2022-23.pdf", "passage": "p. 8: Rigorous Cyber Security audits of the new system", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Audits are asserted; no auditor, standard or date is given. The Protocols, s.8.2.4, refer to 'recommendations of Information Security Audit' without naming it." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-06", "id": "pakistan-citizens-portal", "name": "Pakistan Citizen's Portal", "agency": "Prime Minister's Performance Delivery Unit (PMDU)", "status": "coded", "T": 38.9, "S": 34.7, "TSI": 36.7, "p05": 25, "p95": 48.8, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://citizenportal.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/96d54358f75c.pdf", "passage": "It provides a nation-wide window to connect people with Government Organizations at all levels for raising their issues with authorities, complaints' redressal and suggestions.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "citizenportal.gov.pk (says only that PMDU was 'established in 2013' and 'reorganized'); pmo.gov.pk privacy policy; Google Play listing.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "No statute, rule or notification is cited anywhere the portal is described." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://pmo.gov.pk/pcp-privacypolicy.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/212745068a13.pdf", "passage": "PCP collects images for the identification of users when interacting with government officials.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Images are mentioned; the Play listing says only 'Personal info'. There is no list of the data held (CNIC, phone number, complaint text, location)." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://web.citizenportal.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105615/https://web.citizenportal.gov.pk/", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/3ccbada855d2.pdf", "passage": "NEED HELP? CONTACT US AT: support.pmdu@pmo.gov.pk", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A general support address only." }, "T2.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://pmo.gov.pk/pcp-privacypolicy.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/212745068a13.pdf", "passage": "We may impart vital information to other government organizations and divisions", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Sharing with government bodies is acknowledged; none is named." }, "T2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://web.citizenportal.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105615/https://web.citizenportal.gov.pk/", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/3ccbada855d2.pdf", "passage": "Developed by NITB", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The National Information Technology Board, a government body, is named as developer; the Play listing names it as publisher. A public body acting as outside developer counts; hosting is asked under T2.3 (reading rule R-4)." }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy; citizenportal.gov.pk; web.citizenportal.gov.pk; Google Play listing.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk menu item 'RIGHT OF ACCESS TO INFORMATION 2017' (the link target is '#' and opens nothing); pmo.gov.pk/contactUs.php (an email address only); citizenportal.gov.pk; web.citizenportal.gov.pk.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Prime Minister's Office site lists a Right of Access to Information item whose link is empty." }, "T3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://citizenportal.gov.pk/reprots/PCP-Report-24-09-2025.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/PCP-Report-24-09-2025.pdf", "passage": "Summary of Statistics As on 14-07-2025", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Statistical summaries are published for 2023, 2024 and 2025. The PDF could not be read by machine; from its title it reports figures and does not evaluate the system." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy; citizenportal.gov.pk.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://pmo.gov.pk/pcp-privacypolicy.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/212745068a13.pdf", "passage": "Pakistan Citizen's Portal Privacy Policy", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A privacy policy specific to the portal, linked from the app's store listing. It is not linked from citizenportal.gov.pk itself." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy (no retention); Google Play listing says 'You can request that data be deleted', which is not a retention period.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://pmo.gov.pk/pcp-privacypolicy.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/212745068a13.pdf", "passage": "data gathered by us is utilized distinctly for authentic purposes such as internal audits, improvement in customization and design of our application, and to contact users. We do not utilize, offer, or pass on your data for business purposes.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Images are 'collected solely for the purpose of identification'." }, "S2.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy; citizenportal.gov.pk; Google Play listing.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy; citizenportal.gov.pk; Google Play listing.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://web.citizenportal.gov.pk/", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105615/https://web.citizenportal.gov.pk/", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/3ccbada855d2.pdf", "passage": "NEED HELP? CONTACT US AT: support.pmdu@pmo.gov.pk", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A support address exists. No route for complaints about misuse of portal data, and no response time." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy; citizenportal.gov.pk.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pmo.gov.pk privacy policy (no breach clause); citizenportal.gov.pk press releases.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://pmo.gov.pk/pcp-privacypolicy.php", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pakistan-citizens-portal/212745068a13.pdf", "passage": "These means incorporate, yet are not restricted to singular authentication, the security of transmitted data, security checking, reviewing, and encryption of your data.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Measures asserted; no auditor, standard or date." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-07", "id": "eobi-registry", "name": "Insured persons and employers registry", "agency": "Employees' Old-Age Benefits Institution (EOBI)", "status": "coded", "T": 36.1, "S": 12.5, "TSI": 21.2, "p05": 5.7, "p95": 34.9, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/introduction/enactment.html", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/33a06ae3a01f.pdf", "passage": "Identification & Registration of Insured Persons; Collection of Contribution; ... Provision of Benefits as per Laws", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Registration of employers and insured persons is described on the same page." }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/introduction/enactment.html", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/33a06ae3a01f.pdf", "passage": "Registration of Establishments (Section 11 of EOB Act 1976)", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The registration rules, S.R.O. 709(1)/76 under section 44 of Act XIV of 1976, are reproduced on the EOBI Law page." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/rules/eobilaw.html", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104413/http://www.eobi.gov.pk/rules/eobilaw.html", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/1b93bd3d5c2c.pdf", "passage": "Full particulars of all persons employed by him including the persons in his insurable employment", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The rules and forms show what employers must supply. No list of the personal data EOBI holds." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/network/manage.htm", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104432/http://www.eobi.gov.pk/network/manage.htm", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/6650573b7c8c.pdf", "passage": "Mr Haris Bin Maqsood, Oftg. Dy. Director General (I.T.), EOBI House, 190/B/1, Block-2 PECHS Karachi, 021-99225384", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A named head of IT with a telephone number. The title does not say the post is responsible for the registry or insured persons' data, so this is coded partly disclosed under reading rule R-1." }, "T2.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk About, EOBI Law, Disclaimer, Individual Information, Management pages.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T2.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/announcement/tendersv1.html", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/7f19520ff1b7.pdf", "passage": "Procurement Of Web Hosting Services ... Technical Evaluation Report Of Establishment Of Managed WAN Connectivity", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Tender notices and evaluation reports are published; they were not opened, so contractor names are unconfirmed. The site footer says 'Powered by EOBI IT Department'." }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk Disclaimer; tenders list (a web-hosting procurement is listed; nothing states where data is held).", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk home, site map link, contact, management pages. The home page links a PDF titled 'Compliance Of Orders Of Honourable Pakistan Information Commission', not opened.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/financial-data/ndx-financial-data.htm", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009104526/http://www.eobi.gov.pk/financial-data/ndx-financial-data.htm", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/580452da066f.pdf", "passage": "Balance Sheet & Revenue Accounts 2023-2024 [file name: BS Un-Audited accounts 2023-24]", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Financial statements (marked un-audited) and an actuarial valuation are published. None assesses the registry." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk About, EOBI Law, Disclaimer.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk Disclaimer (copyright and liability only); home; Individual Information page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "No privacy statement of any kind was found." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "EOBI Law page (the rules require employers to preserve records; nothing on EOBI's own retention); Disclaimer.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "EOBI Law page (keyword search: confidential, disclose, secrecy); Disclaimer.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/eobifs/info-ind.htm", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/0a9f447e7d89.pdf", "passage": "Individual Information ... Insured Person/Employee Details ... Pension Claim Status", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "An insured person can look up their employment history and pension claim online." }, "S2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk FAQ page (empty); Individual Information; EOBI Law.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The FAQ page was opened on 9 October 2026 and has a heading and no content." }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "http://www.eobi.gov.pk/helpdesk/helpLinev1.html", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/eobi-registry/c9175df35343.pdf", "passage": "EOBI Help Lines: Islamabad ... Email Address: fpit_isd@eobi.gov.pk; Lahore ... fpit_lhr@eobi.gov.pk; Karachi ... fpit_khi@eobi.gov.pk", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Help lines, plus links to the Citizen's Portal and the Wafaqi Mohtasib. No response time." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk Individual Information; Disclaimer.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk Disclaimer; home-page notices.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eobi.gov.pk Management (an internal audit post exists); tenders; Disclaimer.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-08", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Observation, not a code: on 8 October 2026 the site and its individual-record lookup (fs2e.eobi.gov.pk) were served over plain HTTP; the HTTPS address did not load." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-08", "id": "sbp-ecib", "name": "Electronic Credit Information Bureau (eCIB)", "agency": "State Bank of Pakistan", "status": "coded", "T": 36.1, "S": 52.8, "TSI": 43.7, "p05": 23.5, "p95": 60.4, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "The major purpose of this database is to enable the Financial Institutions(FIs) to know the credit history of their prospective customers thus enabling them to make informed and timely lending decisions.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/our-operations/consumer-protection", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/2888ea0472a7.pdf", "passage": "Established in 1992 under Section 25(A) of the Banking Companies Ordinance, 1962", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "It provides factual position of the borrowers' credit exposure both negative as well as positive as of certain date.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The kind of information is described (credit exposure, overdues, write-offs). No list of the personal data fields held." }, "T1.4": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/help-desk", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/1a7bf049b6db.pdf", "passage": "Help Desk: Consumer Protection Helpdesk; SUNWAI Customer Complaint Service; Focal Persons", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A help desk and the Consumer Protection Department. No named officer for the bureau's data." }, "T2.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "All Banks, Development Financial Institutions (DFIs), Non-Bank Financial Companies (NBFCs), and Micro Finance Banks operating in Pakistan are members of the eCIB database. ... No financial institution can access the eCIB database without obtaining membership", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The page on consumer protection adds 'nearly 100 member institutions'. A class fixed by law whose members SBP lists as licensed institutions counts as named (reading rule R-3)." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "sbp.org.pk consumer protection page; eCIB FAQs; privacy statement.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "sbp.org.pk consumer protection page (says 'eCIB servers', no location); eCIB FAQs; privacy statement.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "sbp.org.pk privacy statement page and site menus (no Right of Access to Information link found); help desk page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "sbp.org.pk consumer protection page; eCIB FAQs. SBP's annual reports and Financial Stability Reviews were not opened.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "sbp.org.pk consumer protection page; eCIB FAQs; privacy statement.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "The eCIB is legally empowered to collect credit information from its member financial institutions. The financial institutions are required to report entire credit records irrespective of any limit to eCIB.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The FAQ explains how borrower data is collected and used. SBP's Privacy Statement covers the website only. There is no privacy notice for borrowers. An FAQ is help text, not a policy or notice, so this is coded partly disclosed under reading rule R-2." }, "S1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "In case of consumer borrower (individual), the CIB maintains the history of financial records of past twelve months.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Stated for individual borrowers. Nothing equivalent for corporate records." }, "S1.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "made available online on request to contributing member financial institutions for the purpose of credit assessment, credit scoring and credit risk management", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The FAQ also says the report is for members' 'internal use'." }, "S2.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eCIB FAQs; consumer protection page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "SBP states the opposite: 'The CIR is a confidential document and cannot be provided to borrowers.' A borrower is pointed to private credit bureaus instead." }, "S2.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/faqs/faqs-credit-information-bureau-cib", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/d417473c8669.pdf", "passage": "Any correction in eCIB data can only be made through the reporting financial institution. ... Please approach your concerned FI and if the dispute/complaint is not resolved then you can approach eCIB through helpdesk", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/our-operations/consumer-protection", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/2888ea0472a7.pdf", "passage": "In any case the complaint must be disposed of within 15 days. However, in fraud-related cases, the final reply to the complainant must be issued within 30 days of lodging the complaint.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The route: the financial institution, then the Banking Mohtasib or SBP's help desk. Time limits are for banking complaints generally." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "eCIB FAQs; consumer protection page; privacy statement.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "sbp.org.pk privacy statement; eCIB FAQs; consumer protection page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.sbp.org.pk/our-operations/consumer-protection", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/sbp-ecib/2888ea0472a7.pdf", "passage": "The eCIB features include separate consumer and corporate reporting, credit history tracking, data correction, encryption, and validation to ensure data integrity.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Measures asserted. No auditor, standard or date." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-09", "id": "pbs-census", "name": "Digital Population and Housing Census 2023", "agency": "Pakistan Bureau of Statistics", "status": "coded", "T": 51.4, "S": 30.6, "TSI": 39.6, "p05": 21, "p95": 56.4, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/census/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/8e7492b27031.pdf", "passage": "The Population and Housing Census is crucial National exercise linked with provision of data for key policy making matters regarding development programs, political representation and resource allocation which has far reaching impact.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T1.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/data-dissemination/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/e0e816699364.pdf", "passage": "The Policy operationalises PBS's mandate under the General Statistics (Re-organization) Act, 2011", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The Act (Act No. XIV of 2011) is published on the site; section 31 provides for the population census." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/EnumerationFormIndividual.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105854/https://www.pbs.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/EnumerationFormIndividual.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/EnumerationFormIndividual.pdf", "passage": "Enumeration Form – Individual", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The individual enumeration form is published (one page, in Urdu), with sections for basic questions, education, economic activity, migration and disability. Fields can be read off the form; there is no list presented as what the census database holds, so this is partly disclosed under the codebook." }, "T1.4": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/contact-1/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/50d3ac3f41b3.pdf", "passage": "Member (Census & Surveys) Mr. Ayazuddin +92 51 9106552", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A named senior officer for censuses, with a telephone number. The post is named for the census, which meets reading rule R-1." }, "T2.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/data-dissemination/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/e0e816699364.pdf", "passage": "Tier 4 — Non-Disseminable: Identifiable source data, frames, credentials — no external release; authorized internal/inter-agency use only.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Inter-agency use of identifiable data is acknowledged; no body is named. Section 30 of the Act allows joint collections whose data is 'shared between the agreeing parties'." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/census/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/8e7492b27031.pdf", "passage": "It involved procurement of 126,000 secured tablets, development of software ..., integration of the enabled tablets with Telco networks for instant transfer of data to secured servers", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Procurement and outside systems are acknowledged; no supplier is named on the pages read." }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pbs.gov.pk census page ('secured servers', no location); Data Dissemination Policy; About page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pbs.gov.pk About page (links a budget statement filed under the Right of Access to Information Act 2017; no designated officer or request procedure found); contact list.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.2": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/PES-Report.pdf", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009105949/https://www.pbs.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/PES-Report.pdf", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/PES-Report.pdf", "passage": "Post Enumeration Survey, 7th Population and Housing Census - 2023, First Ever Digital Census, Pakistan Bureau of Statistics", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A 70-page report assessing the coverage of the census, linked from the census page as 'Post Enumeration Survey (PES) Report'. Its publication date is not stated; a file name on the same page suggests October 2023. Where a date is uncertain the benefit goes to the agency (reading rule R-6)." }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pbs.gov.pk census page; Data Dissemination Policy; About page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/data-dissemination/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/e0e816699364.pdf", "passage": "The Policy adopts \"open by default, confidential by design and equal access\" as its operating rule. ... Microdata access related to Census, Industry and Agriculture shall instead be determined through proportionate tiers", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A published data policy that names the census and says how identifiable data is handled, written for data users, not for the households counted. Counted in full under reading rule R-2." }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Data Dissemination Policy; General Statistics (Reorganization) Act 2011 (keyword search); census page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.3": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/General_Statistics_Reorganization_ACT_2011.pdf", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/General_Statistics_Reorganization_ACT_2011.pdf", "passage": "s.28(1): All answers to the questions received and all information and returns furnished under this Act shall be confidential and shall not be,- (a) used for any purpose other than compilation of statistics under this Act; (b) published in a form which may disclose the state of affairs of any particular individual", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "A statutory purpose limit, with a criminal penalty for disclosure (p. 18 of the Act)." }, "S2.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pbs.gov.pk census page; Data Dissemination Policy; FAQs.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pbs.gov.pk census page; FAQs; Data Dissemination Policy.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "pbs.gov.pk contact list (staff directory only); census page; FAQs.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Data Dissemination Policy; census page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "Data Dissemination Policy; census page; About page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://www.pbs.gov.pk/census/", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "evidence/pbs-census/8e7492b27031.pdf", "passage": "procurement of 126,000 secured tablets ... instant transfer of data to secured servers", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Security is asserted. No auditor, standard or date." } } }, { "register_no": "PDO-10", "id": "safe-city-islamabad", "name": "Safe City Islamabad surveillance and analytics", "agency": "Islamabad Capital Territory Police", "status": "coded", "T": 26.4, "S": 4.2, "TSI": 10.5, "p05": 2.5, "p95": 18.1, "indicators": { "T1.1": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009110033/https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "evidence_file": "evidence/safe-city-islamabad/d84ba9f130df.pdf", "passage": "The project combines advanced surveillance technologies, artificial intelligence, integrated communication systems, and citizen-centric digital services ... enables monitoring, rapid emergency response, coordinated resource deployment, crime prevention, and evidence-based investigations.", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "The page also describes 'Hunch Lab (Predictive Policing)'." }, "T1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; About ICTP not opened; site menus (no laws or legal page).", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "No statute, rule or notification is cited for the surveillance system or the predictive-policing tool." }, "T1.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009110033/https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "evidence_file": "evidence/safe-city-islamabad/d84ba9f130df.pdf", "passage": "Artificial intelligence and video analytics assist in monitoring public spaces, identifying suspicious activities, supporting investigations, analyzing movement patterns", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "What is analysed is described in general terms. Nothing lists what is recorded about people (faces, number plates, locations) or held in 'Hotel Eye' guest records." }, "T1.4": { "code": 1, "source_url": "https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009110033/https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "evidence_file": "evidence/safe-city-islamabad/d84ba9f130df.pdf", "passage": "Mr. Muhammad Ateeque Tahir, DIG Law & Order, DG Safe City, 051-9259381, 051-9259384", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Named command with telephone numbers." }, "T2.1": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009110033/https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "evidence_file": "evidence/safe-city-islamabad/d84ba9f130df.pdf", "passage": "facilitates communication among relevant departments", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Coordination with other departments is mentioned; none is named." }, "T2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; tenders page ('No active tenders available at the moment'); contact page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T2.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; contact page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk site menus (no Right to Information page or officer); contact page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page (news items only); media and notices sections not opened in full.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "T3.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk site menus and footer (no privacy policy or terms); Safe City page; complaint form.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S1.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "Nothing says how long camera footage or analytics results are kept." }, "S1.3": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; services list.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; services list.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S2.3": { "code": 0.5, "source_url": "https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "archive_url": "https://web.archive.org/web/20261009110033/https://islamabadpolice.gov.pk/division.php?slug=safe-city-islamabad", "evidence_file": "evidence/safe-city-islamabad/d84ba9f130df.pdf", "passage": "Complaint Management System (CMS): A transparent digital platform for registering, monitoring, and resolving public complaints related to policing services ... 1715 IGP Complaint Cell", "search_log": "", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "General police complaint routes. Nothing covers misuse of surveillance data and no response time is stated." }, "S2.4": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.1": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; site menus.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" }, "S3.2": { "code": 0, "source_url": "", "archive_url": "", "evidence_file": "", "passage": "", "search_log": "islamabadpolice.gov.pk Safe City page; site menus.", "reason": "", "checked_on": "2026-10-09", "coder": "Pakistan Data Observatory", "verified_by": "N", "note": "" } } } ]